Last Update:
Thursday November 22, 2018
|
|
[Home] |
Volume 19 Issue 2 Pages 62 - 110 (October 2002) The River Otter (Lontra canadensis) in Clarcke County (Georgia, USA) - Survey, Food Habits and Environmental Factors Rienk Noordhuis Borgmanweg 22, 7558 PN Hengelo, The Netherlands, e-mail: rinoordhuis@hotmail.com
INTRODUCTION In the early 1950s, river otters (Lontra canadensis) were considered rare in the Georgia Piedmont area (JENKINS, 1953). No records are known from Clarcke and surrounding counties from those years, though the original distribution included the whole of Georgia. The most probable cause of their decline and subsequent eradication was over-trapping (JENKINS, 1983). However, by 1970 river otters had recolonized the Georgia Piedmont area (JENKINS, pers. comm.). This recovery took place while pollution was dramatically affecting ecosystems all over the world. In 1993, the status of otters in Clarcke county was assessed through a survey of local rivers for presence (tracks and spraints, and a survey of pollution status through analysis of spraints and locally caught fish for heavy metals (Hg and Pb). Data on organochlorine and polychlorinated biphenyl (PCBs) loading was assessed from previous studies. The results were compared to reports in literature to see if food habits and pollution status have changed over time. In addition, a comparison was made with food habits of river otters in the nearby Smokey Mountains, where the rivers are clear, to see how water with a low transparency affects their food habits and the possible role of underwater scent in searching for food in turbid water is discussed MATERIALS AND METHODS The study site comprises most of Clarcke County and parts of the surrounding counties in the Piedmont area of Georgia. Most otter spraints were collected in and around the town of Athens. Athens is a medium sized town with approximately 80,000 inhabitants. The North and Middle Oconee River both run through Athens and join south of the town. The rivers and creeks are provided everywhere with a dense riparian vegetation, also within the town limits. According to ODUM (pers. comm.) a lot of this riparian vegetation has been restored in the last forty years to prevent erosion. Large trees, such as sycamore (Platanus occidentalis) and river birch {Betula nigra), are abundant along the rivers and creeks. Rapids, rocks and logjams are common. All these structures are known to be important to river otters (MELQUIST and HORNOCKER, 1983; MACDONALD and MASON, 1983). Beavers are abundant everywhere in the study area. It is well known that river otters benefit from the activities and dens of beavers (TUMLISON et al., 1982) The soil type is sandy loam and the pH of the North Oconee River is 7.35, total Organic Carbon content in summer is about 2.6ppm, and the total calcium concentration is about 5.2ppm. All year round, but especially in winter, the rivers and creeks are loaded with silt. Underwater visibility usually does not exceed 20cm. In order to get an impression of the status of the river otter in the study area, the rivers and creeks were searched for signs of this animal. About 16 stretches of approximately 100m of river or creek bank were surveyed. Sand strips, rocks, rapids, logs and banks were checked for tracks and spraints. Looking for 'positive sites' of otters is one mean of surveying an otter population (MASON and MACDONALD, 1987). When footprints were found, the prints of the hind foot were measured. By doing this it became possible to estimate if there was more than one individual present at a certain site. Adult male footprints are usually much larger (wider than 7cm) than female or subadult male footprints (MASON and MACDONALD, 1986). Spraints, not older than about two weeks and non-weathered, were collected from January through the end of March and from July until the end of September 1993. After collection, they were dried and stored. Two hundred and fourteen spraints from nine different sites in the study area (of which four were situated within the city limits) were collected on visits every fortnight. These were used to determine food habits. The spraints were shaken in water containing commercial washing powder and then rinsed on sieves with mesh sizes of 2 and 0.5mm resp. and all the food remains of each sample were than collected from the sieves and dried. Fish bones and scales and remains of other vertebrates were identified with the help of the bone collection of the Museum of Natural History in Athens and with LEE et al. (1980). Skeletal remains or gastroliths indicated the presence of crayfish. Crayfish were keyed out according to HOBBS (1981). The importance of the different types of food item is expressed as frequency of occurrence and relative frequency. The frequency of occurrence was calculated by dividing the number of occurrences of a particular food item by the total amount of spraints. The relative frequency was calculated by dividing the number of occurrences by the sum of the occurrences of all food items. During January, February, and March, a total of 40 spraints, containing mainly crayfish remains, and a total of 11 spraints, containing mainly fish remains, were collected from 8 different sites in the study area. These spraints were selected from spraint sites for heavy metal analysis. Four of these were situated within the city limits; one site was upstream, and three sites downstream of Athens. Three to eight spraints per site were dried and ground in a glass mortar and analyzed for Pb and Hg. For the analysis of Pb, 1g dried spraint was muffled and dissolved in 10ml 30% HCL and 10% HNO3. The Pb concentration was determined with a Thermo Jarrell-Ash 965 Inductivity Coupled Argon Plasma (ICAP) with a detection limit of 1ppb for Pb. For the analysis of Hg, 1.5g was muffled and dissolved in 20ml 15% HCl and 5% HNO3 and analyzed with an AVA800 Thermo Jarrell-Ash mercury analyzer with a detection limit of 1ppb. Fifteen crayfish and three small catfish were caught in 'minnow traps', baited with catfood, in the North Oconee river. Five Procambarus spiculifer were caught just north of Athens. Five Procambarus spiculifer, five Cambarus bartonii and three small snail bullheads Ameiurus brunneus were caught close to the center of Athens. From the crayfish and the catfish, the muscle, intestine and fat bodies were freeze-dried. Five samples (5 P. spiculifer from north of Athens; 5 P. spiculifer from Athens; 5 C. bartonii; 1 larger catfish and 2 small catfish) were analyzed for mercury in the same way as described for spraints. RESULTS Signs Twelve of the sixteen surveyed river or creek stretches (75%) showed signs of otters. In the study area, nine spraint sites were found. Spraints were collected repeatedly from these sites. The average amount of spraints collected on the visits to the sites was 5.3. At eight spraint sites otter prints could be found as well. Four spraint sites were on sand strips; four were on banks on the forest floor and one was on rock. The sprainting activity was higher in winter than in summer; four spraint sites regularly used in winter were abandoned in the summer. One spraint site sparsely used in winter was more frequently used in summer and another one was moved 50m in summer. At four spraint sites, signs of heavy rolling in coarse sand were observed. At three of these places sliding trails were also found on the sandy banks. One winter site was on a creek in a park close to the center of Athens. Spraints were found at the entrance of a simple beaver den. The measurements of prints from the hind foot were the smallest measured during the study (5.3cm). Two large beaver dens in banks outside the city limits appeared to have been used by otters. One den was heavily sprainted upon but the spraints were old when found. The second one had a spraint site very nearby and trails led from and to the den. The site was frequently used in winter and irregularly in summer. Food habits
One third of the winter food and two thirds of the summer food consisted of crayfish. Ninety percent of the crayfish remains could be identified as Procambarus spiculifer. This species can be seen and caught easily in the rivers and creeks around Athens where it is abundant. It is restricted to lotic habitats and can be found under stones, in litter and among roots. Procambarus spiculifer does not usually make burrows (HOBBS, 1981). About ten percent of the crayfish remains were identified as Cambarus sp.. Five species are known from the area (HOBBS, 1981), but Cambarus latimanus and C. bartonii are the species most likely to be caught. These two species only burrow under certain circumstances, while the remaining three spend all their lives in a burrow (HOBBS, 1981). Fish are the most important source of food in the winter months. Fifty-nine percent (relative frequency) of the food remains were fish, against less than half of this in summer. Sunfishes (Centrarchidae) form the most important group eaten. It is hard to identify sunfishes to the species level; however, it was possible to identify bones and otoliths of the largemouth bass (Micropterus salmoides) and the otoliths of bluegill sunfish (Lepomis macrochirus) in this study. Micropterus salmoides was found rarely. About one third of the sunfish ototliths were bluegill and most of the remaining part was thought to be redbreast sunfish (L. auritus), considering its abundance in the area. Some spraints from winter consisted of only very small sunfish olotiths. They were of redbreasts or bluegills of the 0-generation. The largest redbreast found was estimated at about 20cm. Most sunfishes caught were relatively small. Minnows were second in importance in the winter and the remains identified belonged either to creek chub {Semotilus atriomaculans) or bluehead chub (Nocomis leptocephalus). Because the otter eats pectoral spines of catfish, these bones can help to identify the species of catfish eaten and to estimate the fish length (PALOUMPIS, 1978). Most catfish caught were small, one brown bullhead (Ameiurus nebulosus) however was estimated at 28cm. Almost all suckers caught were large individuals, estimated to have been three to five years of age; judging from the annual rings of the scales found. The larger individuals were estimated at about 40cm. In 6% of the winter spraints small molluscs were found. These remains were usually associated with catfish remains and were therefore not counted as otter food. Lead and mercury levels DISCUSSION Food habits It could be concluded that there was little change in the food habits of the inland river otter in the southeast since the nineteen seventies. Crayfish, as part of the river otter's diet, is reported in many food studies. In the Smokey Mountains National Park, 95% of the summer spraints contained crayfish (GRIESS, 1987). McDANIEL (1963) examined 63 stomachs from Florida otters caught in the trapping season and noted that crayfish had a relative frequency of 17.7%. KNUDSEN and HALE (1968) found a higher percentage offish in winter than in other seasons, whilst crayfish was eaten less frequently in this season. PARK (1971) suggests that otters eat what is available and accessible in the aquatic habitat; but could crayfish be a preferred food item? Because of the abundance and diversity of crayfish in the southeast (PENNAK, 1978), one could expect that crayfish would be eaten more frequently in this area than elsewhere. The occurrence of crayfish in otter food of, for example, New York State and the Great Lakes Area (HAMILTON, 1961; KNUDSEN and HALE, 1968) is indeed lower than in the research of LAUHACHINDA and HILL (1977), GRIESS (1987) and the present research. However, in the three former mentioned papers, crayfish is said to be an important food source. Pond turtles are very abundant in the study area, but only once was a pond turtle found as food (Table 1). A similar observation was made by GREER (1955). It may be that turtles are eaten more frequently but that the shell, skin and bones are left behind. This may also be true with freshwater mussels. If the shells were not eaten, it would be hard to detect consumption without direct observation. Walruses feed largely on molluscs, but remains were never found in their stomachs (LOCKLEY, 1967). Siltation and food habits In areas with healthy otter populations in Spain and Greece, MASON and MACDONALD (1987) found, on average, about 75% of the searched stretches positive for otters. The river otters in our study area do not, therefore, appear to be limited by the heavy siltation. Does turbid water change the river otter's food habits? The large amount of crayfish taken could be partly induced by the heavy siltation, since crayfish are easy to catch, even in turbid water. The research of GRIESS (1987) on Abrams Creek in the Smokey Mountains National Park showed that, from April to September, crayfish was the most frequently taken food item with a frequency of occurrence of 95%, compared to 98% around Athens. Fish was encountered in 90% and 35% of the spraints resp. The water of Abrams Creek is very clear (GRIESS, pers. comm.). It cannot be concluded that the high relative frequency of occurrence of crayfish during summer around Athens is induced by heavy siltation, although relatively more crayfish (66% compared to 40%) and less fish (24% compared to 38%) were taken in summer around Athens than on Abrams Creek. Data on the relative abundance of crayfish in both places are lacking, but it is clear that crayfish is an important food source at both locations. In the present research, the majority of fish taken were Centrarchids. Apart from Centrarchidae, the Cyprinidae, Catostomidae and Ictaluridae were also important, the majority of them bottom feeders. In the research of GRIESS (1987), otters showed a preference for Cyprinidae and Catostomidae amongst fish, the species taken of these groups being mostly bottom feeders. Centrarchidae and Ictaluridae were not common in Abrams Creek; however, more bottom feeding fish were taken in the clear water of Abrams Creek than in the turbid water of Clarcke County. The preference for bottom feeding fish does not, therefore, appear to be related to turbidity. Underwater scent as an adaptation to turbidity PARK (1971) points out that much of the river otters' food is caught by 'rooting around' in the mud or debris at the bottom of ponds and creeks. This behavior was also often observed in captive otters from local origin in a small zoo in Athens (own observation, 1993). PARK (1971) states that 'undoubtedly the vibrissae are important to locate food in the mud'. In the present research, 34% of the diet from January through March consisted of crayfish, however, crayfish are not active during January and February (HOBBS, 1981) and may be very well hidden. MASON and MACDONALD (1986) state that otters in Great Britain forage for hibernating frogs in autumn and winter. KNUDSEN and HALE (1968) explained frogs and insects in the winter food by assuming that the otters did considerable digging in the bottom sediment. Hidden immobile animals, such as crayfish in a layer of leaves or a hibernating frog, cannot be detected easily with the vibrissae. Scent may, therefore, play a major role to detect prey under these circumstances. De JONGH (1986) showed that otters could pick up chemical stimuli with their rhinarium ('wet nose') and he speculated that scent might play an important role in locating fish at close range. Threatened sunfish, chub, catfish, crayfish, etc. may also hide under stones where vibrissae cannot always reach. Such a hidden animal in turbid water may be rediscovered by scent rather than by touch. Scent seems to be generally underestimated or forgotten by several authors as a tool in hunting. The use of underwater scent may be of extra use in turbid water. The most conspicuous difference between the river otter and the European otter is that the river otter has a much larger rhinarium (MASON and MACDONALD, 1986). Because of this difference, it is possible that the river otter is better adapted to living in turbid water. PCBs, organochlorines and heavy metals The levels of lead in the spraints analyzed in the present research were comparable to, or lower than, that from the 450 spraints collected in four different areas in Great Britain (MASON and MACDONALD, 1986). The mercury levels in the spraints of the present research were much lower. In the crayfish and fish analyzed no elevated Hg-levels could be detected. OSOWSKI et al. (1995) examined trapped mink from 1989 -1991 in North and South Carolina and Georgia. They suggest that mink from the Coastal Plain had suffered population declines because of elevated mercury levels. Also, PCB levels were elevated compared to the controls. Mink from the Piedmont area were used as controls. Average PCB levels in 14 mink from three different counties just west of Clarcke County were 0.005 ppm (wet weight liver) while mercury levels were 0.57 ppm (wet weight in kidney). The level of organochlorines and PCB's was recently measured in a dam lake fed by the Oconee River south of Athens (Department of Natural Resources, EPA, Atlanta; personal communication). The levels of these pollutants were very low. The Oconee rivershed is known to be more pristine than many other riversheds in Georgia (Freeman, pers. comm.). From the above it could be concluded with some optimism, that river otters in the study area were, and are presently, not exposed to critical levels of organochlorines, PCB's, lead and mercury. Micropollutants were probably not a real obstacle for the recovery of the river otter in the area. The restoration of riparian forests, reduced trapping and the return of beavers, however, may have facilitated the return of the otter. CONCLUSIONS At present, the river otter population in Clarcke County in the Piedmont area is well developed. The food of the river otter in the study area consists mostly of crayfish and sunfish. Especially in the summer, crayfish is very important. When comparing food habits in winter in the 1970s (LAUACHlNDA and HILL, 1977) in Alabama and Georgia (when siltation was already widespread) with data of the 1990s, little difference was found. Food habits of the river otter are similar in both clear and turbid water. The problem of siltation does not, therefore, appear to affect the river otter population or change its food habits. Micropollutant levels in river otters in the area have been relatively low in the past, and remain so presently, as the exposure to micropollutants still seems to be below critical levels. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS - This study would not have been possible without the cooperation of the Museum of Natural History in Athens. Special thanks goes to Dr. E.J Reitz, Amy Lynn Edwards and Tracey Jones. Thanks go to Becky Auxier of the Chemical Analysis Laboratory for giving me the opportunity to analyze samples, Terry Moore for helping me with the direction of the research and the fieldwork, Prof. Jenkins who gave me information about otters in the past, Jane M. Griess for being so helpful and sending me her thesis and other literature, and to Bud J. Freeman for helping me with fish distribution. REFERENCESBurkhead, N.M., Williams, J.D., Freeman, B.J. 1992.
A river under siege. Is the beautiful Etowah of the cherokees succumbing to
Atlanta's urban sprawl? Georgia Wildlife Summer 1992. Résumé : La Loutre de Rivière Nord-Américaine (Lontra
canadensis) dans le Comté de Clarcke (Georgia, USA): Étude du Régime
Alimentaire et des Facteurs Environnementaux Resumen: La Nutria de Río (Lontra canadensis)
en el Condado Clarcke (Georgia, USA): un Relevamiento, Hábitos Alimenticios y
Factores Ambientales. |
[Copyright © 2006 - 2050 IUCN/SSC OSG] | [Home] | [Contact Us] |